FEATURES

The Jury Room: Case 3 - Susan May
By Dave Macleod, Friday 26th May 2017

On March 12th 1992, in a quiet residential road in Greater Manchester, 89 year-old widow Hilda Marchbank was found dead. Lying in her own bed she had been beaten and suffocated with her pillow during the night. The murder of this vulnerable elderly woman shocked and horrified the small town of Royton in which she lived.

It initially appeared that she had fallen victim to a bungled robbery but crucially there were no signs of forced entry and nothing appeared to have been taken, leading detectives to question whether the robbery might have been staged.

Eighteen days after the brutal attack, the woman’s niece was arrested when incriminating forensic evidence was found. Her name was Susan May and she had been Hilda’s primary carer, the person Hilda relied upon the most. Susan May vehemently denied having any involvement with her beloved aunt’s death.

It was Susan who found Hilda’s body, during one of her regular visits to her home on the morning after the murder. Although Susan was not initially a suspect, there were three bloody marks on a wall at the crime scene and it was discovered the left hand mark on the wall had been made by May’s hand.

During the trial, the prosecution’s case was that the marks on the wall were made by May in her aunt’s blood as she felt her way along the wall after committing the murder.

In 1993, Susan May was convicted of the murder of Hilda Marchbank and sentenced to life imprisonment. Following her conviction she made two appeals, both which failed, due to a weak case from her defence.

She continued to protest her innocence whilst in jail and appealed twice. Both appeals were rejected. She was released in 2005 on parole. After her release Susan was diagnosed with breast cancer, and, whilst fighting the disease, she determinedly fought to clear her name. In 2013, just weeks before a decision was due on whether to grant her leave for a third appeal, she died a convicted woman.

Susan May’s supporters claim new evidence proves the marks, which formed the main crux of the prosecutions case, were made from sweat, not blood and made before the murder occurred. They feel this new forensic report, combined with evidence of botched tests and police inadequacies, could finally clear her name and prove that Susan May was the victim of a cruel miscarriage of justice.

Before Susan May died she said: "All this new evidence points to the fact that my conviction is unsafe. If the jury heard the case as it is now, with some witnesses discredited and without the main plank of their case - the so-called blood marks - they couldn't come to the same conclusion."

Click here for more information about The Jury Room on CBS Reality, including the podcast, gallery and cast video biographies.


Related show tags: THE JURY ROOM
MORE FEATURES
Snapped: Killer Couples season 13 begins this October on CBS Reality
By James W, Sunday 29th August 2021
Killer Couples

Snapped: Killer Couples is a gripping series that features couples whose passion drove them to commit terrible criminal acts. Through re-creations and first-hand accounts, each episode delves into the stories behind the couples' romance, how their relationship evolved once love transformed into manipulation and what ultimately drove them to commit crimes.

From a teenage couple who embark on a multi-state crime spree to lesbian lovers who stop at nothing to eliminate one of their husbands; viewers are given unprecedented access into these relationships.

Snapped: Killer Couples Season 13 begins 4th October at 10pm on CBS Reality.

SHARE: READ MORE
Homicide's Elite: Season 3 continues in October on CBS Reality
Posted on Sunday 29th August 2021
Homicides Elite

Detectives David Quinn and Vince Velazquez have worked hundreds of homicides together - if these two are on the case, the bad guys are going to prison.

In episode six of season three of Homicide's Elite, Vince and Quinn are contacted about a cold case murder from 1988, when Leonard Hill was found shot to death and left on the side of the road in Mechanicsville.

Twenty-eight years after the murder, his son, Antonio Taylor, wants his dad’s killer brought to justice and has requested the case be reopened. After days digging into the case file and getting nowhere, Quinn and Vince are at a dead end... until Antonio reveals he may know more than he had previously let on. He tells Q...

SHARE: READ MORE
Injustice with Nancy Grace is a CBS Reality channel premiere in October
Posted on Sunday 29th August 2021
Injustice with Nancy Grace

Renowned legal analyst and former felony prosecutor Nancy Grace draws upon her vast knowledge and expertise as she unravels mysterious and enthralling true crime cases, the acclaimed series Injustice with Nancy Grace.

Each standalone episode delves into a captivating, multi-layered story of injustice, from wrongful accusations to botched investigations to unjust sentences and more.

Through first-hand interviews, archival footage and Nancy's unique perspective, the series shines a light on these untold cases and the fight for justice.

Injustice with Nancy Grace begins 6th October at 10pm on CBS Reality.

SHARE: READ MORE
Murder by the Sea: Season 6 starts this September on CBS Reality
Posted on Sunday 29th August 2021
Murder by the Sea Season 6

Crime historian and author Dr Nell Darby reprises her role as the host of Murder by the Sea in season six, as she investigates further cases of seaside murders, including a case in which Philip Manning, the perpetrator, sparked a nationwide manhunt after killing his wife in a small town near Newport, Wales, on Christmas Day 1994. And the murder of Margaret Wilson which took over three years to solve, with the police interviewing hundreds of leads and utilising state of the art technology to eventually catch the perpetrator.

In this new series of Murder by the Sea, viewers will join Nell on a journey to the cliff's edge, where the land meets the sea, and where life mee...

SHARE: READ MORE
When "I do" can be a deadly answer! Fatal Vows continues on CBS Reality this September
Posted on Sunday 8th August 2021
FATAL VOWS Season 4

Your wedding day is supposed to be the happiest day of your life – how do you get from there to the desperately sad - and terrifying - moment when one of you is staring death in the face, begging for your life?

Season 4 of Fatal Vows traces the deadly and tragic path from “I do” to “you’re dead” in thirteen stories of marriages beyond repair. The series uses personal interviews, family photos, expert commentary and dramatic reenactments to understand how the relationships so tragically deteriorate. We’ve all wanted to kill our spouses, so what leads one partner to commit that final, gruesome act?

Fatal Vows answers that question in episodes that range from ...

SHARE: READ MORE
Donal MacIntyre is back on CBS Reality in August
Posted on Monday 5th July 2021
Donal Macintyres Murder Files Season 2

Renowned undercover reporter and criminologist Donal MacIntyre returns to present the second season of this CBS Reality Original series examining some of the most intriguing and challenging crimes of recent years, as seen through the first-hand experiences of the men and women who ensured justice was carried out.

Each episode includes an in-depth interview with the lead detective who solved the case in question. Using dramatic reconstruction, archive footage, and police tapes, MacIntyre takes the viewer through all the twists and turns, the setbacks and the dangers, to the turning point that led to the case being solved. The viewer will find out...

SHARE: READ MORE
Old cases are reopened this July in Cold Justice
Posted on Friday 18th June 2021
Cold Justice

Cold Justice follows former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and a team of crime scene investigators and detectives as they crack cold cases.

Kelly Siegler, a Texas prosecutor for 21 years who has successfully tried 68 murder cases, and her team of crime scene investigators and trained detectives, put their vast knowledge and experience to work helping local law-enforcement officers and families of violent-crime victims get to the truth.

With a fresh set of eyes on old evidence, superior interrogation skills and access to advanced DNA technology and lab testing, Siegler is determined to bring about a legal and emotional resolution.

Taking on a different unsolved crime each episode, ...

SHARE: READ MORE
Premiere episodes of Season 3 of Evidence of Evil in June
Posted on Monday 17th May 2021
Evidence of Evil

Season 3 of the original true crime series Evidence of Evil explores and reconstructs some of the most intriguing and startling criminal cases of the past two decades, where technology changed the course of the investigations and brought the guilty to justice.

Featuring key witness testimony, new interviews, reconstructed sequences and archive footage, the series showcases the hard work and dedication of investigators, police, scientists, and other experts in their fields.

Premiere episodes of Evidence of Evil from 7th June at 10pm on CBS Reality.

SHARE: READ MORE
Fatal Vows Season 3
Posted on Thursday 1st April 2021

FATAL VOWS
Season 3
Weeknights at 22:00, from 6th May until 24th May. 

Fatal Vows traces the deadly and tragic path from “I do” to “you’re dead” in stories of marriages beyond repair. The series uses personal interviews, family photos, expert commentary and dramatic reenactments to understand how the relationships deteriorate so tragically.

Fatal Vows answers the who, what, when, where, how and why it happened, showing us again that… Love may be blind, and marriage bliss, but divorce is murder.

Each hour-long episode of Fatal Vows objectively profiles the details of a settled and closed murder case associated with a couple's divorce.  Each episode is objectiv...

SHARE: READ MORE
PICK OF THE WEEK
Ice Cold Killers
ICE COLD KILLERS
Friday 1 October
10.00 PM
Murderers And Their Mothers
MURDERERS AND THEIR MOTHERS
Saturday 25 September
9.00 PM
Medical Detectives
MEDICAL DETECTIVES
Saturday 2 October
10.00 PM