The Jury Room: Case 3 - Susan May
By CBS Reality, Friday 26th May 2017

On March 12th 1992, in a quiet residential road in Greater Manchester, 89 year-old widow Hilda Marchbank was found dead. Lying in her own bed she had been beaten and suffocated with her pillow during the night. The murder of this vulnerable elderly woman shocked and horrified the small town of Royton in which she lived.

It initially appeared that she had fallen victim to a bungled robbery but crucially there were no signs of forced entry and nothing appeared to have been taken, leading detectives to question whether the robbery might have been staged.

Eighteen days after the brutal attack, the woman’s niece was arrested when incriminating forensic evidence was found. Her name was Susan May and she had been Hilda’s primary carer, the person Hilda relied upon the most. Susan May vehemently denied having any involvement with her beloved aunt’s death.

It was Susan who found Hilda’s body, during one of her regular visits to her home on the morning after the murder. Although Susan was not initially a suspect, there were three bloody marks on a wall at the crime scene and it was discovered the left hand mark on the wall had been made by May’s hand.

During the trial, the prosecution’s case was that the marks on the wall were made by May in her aunt’s blood as she felt her way along the wall after committing the murder.

In 1993, Susan May was convicted of the murder of Hilda Marchbank and sentenced to life imprisonment. Following her conviction she made two appeals, both which failed, due to a weak case from her defence.

She continued to protest her innocence whilst in jail and appealed twice. Both appeals were rejected. She was released in 2005 on parole. After her release Susan was diagnosed with breast cancer, and, whilst fighting the disease, she determinedly fought to clear her name. In 2013, just weeks before a decision was due on whether to grant her leave for a third appeal, she died a convicted woman.

Susan May’s supporters claim new evidence proves the marks, which formed the main crux of the prosecutions case, were made from sweat, not blood and made before the murder occurred. They feel this new forensic report, combined with evidence of botched tests and police inadequacies, could finally clear her name and prove that Susan May was the victim of a cruel miscarriage of justice.

Before Susan May died she said: "All this new evidence points to the fact that my conviction is unsafe. If the jury heard the case as it is now, with some witnesses discredited and without the main plank of their case - the so-called blood marks - they couldn't come to the same conclusion."

Click here for more information about The Jury Room on CBS Reality, including the podcast, gallery and cast video biographies.

Related show tags: THE JURY ROOM
What Sins & Secrets will we reveal in March?
Posted on Monday 5th March 2018

Exclusive to CBS Reality, Sins & Secrets reveals the grim truth of the criminal underworld which can be found in every neighbourhood.

As slick and pacey as a contemporary cop drama, this new series uncovers brutal crimes which shook neighbourhoods leaving communities wondering who would be next and paranoid of every stranger in town.

This series shows no one can ever be sure of what is really happening behind the net curtains of suburbia. Using real life footage, dramatic reconstructions and witness interviews, the sins and secrets criminals have tried so desperately to bury are exposed.

Sins & Secrets Season 4 starts March 15th at 10pm.

Donal MacIntyre’s Murder Files remain open during March
Posted on Monday 5th March 2018

Donal MacIntyre’s Murder Files is presented by renowned undercover reporter and criminologist Donal MacIntyre, who examines some of the most horrific and fascinating crimes of recent times through the first-hand experiences of the men and women who ensured justice was carried out.

Each episode includes an in-depth interview with the key detective who solved the case in question. Using dramatic reconstruction, archive footage and police tapes, MacIntyre takes the viewer through all the twists and turns, the setbacks and the dangers, to the turning point that led to the case being solved. The viewer will find out what it takes to solve a complex case while witnessing ...

Donal MacIntyre’s Murder Files open in February
Posted on Thursday 15th February 2018

In the bold new studio based series, Donal MacIntyre's Murder Files the renowned undercover reporter and crime journalist examines the most horrific and fascinating crimes.

In-depth interviews by Donal with the individuals who were central to solving each case - from the detective on duty to the undercover agent to the forensic scientist – are the spine of each episode. Donal will expertly lead them through their story step by step, uncovering the dramatic twists and turns of each and every case. The stories will be illustrated by dramatic reconstruction of the case and archive, including police tapes and undercover evidence.

Through these intimate and probing interviews, Donal will also reveal th...

Sniff out crime with the Dog Patrol
Posted on Thursday 25th January 2018

This exciting series follows the integral roles that working dogs and their handlers play on the frontline protecting our streets, prisons, national parks, airports and borders.

We’re right in with the action following the real scenarios that unfold as a result of these dedicated hardworking dogs, in the Correction Service, Customs, MAF, Aviation Security, Department of Conservation and Search and Rescue. While examining the relationship between these loyal canines and their handlers, we get an intimate insight of how they mutually perform their jobs. We explore the bond each duo have together and watch each dog’s unique style of operating.

Dog Patrol weekdays at 4pm and 4:30pm fro...

Toxic relationships are uncovered in February
Posted on Wednesday 24th January 2018

Uncovering: Intimate Partner Abuse (Wednesday 7th February at 10pm) is a one-hour CBS Reality Original documentary which explores and highlights the different elements of domestic abuse, including coercion and stalking, that so often lead to serious violence or homicide.

The programme reveals the patterns and warning signs that are present in almost all abusive relationships and explains the definitive characteristics of most abusers.

Jemma Cadle and Samantha Howlett describe their abusive relationships and how with support they eventually regained control and secured convictions. Other key contributors include criminologist and leading expert in domestic homicide, Jane Monckton-Smith (pictu...

January on CBS Reality
Posted on Tuesday 2nd January 2018

Season 2
Wednesdays at 22:00 from 3rd till 31st January

This thrilling 5X60 CBS Reality Original series takes a fresh approach by bringing to life the nerve-jangling real audio taken from the killers’ confessions, which in season 2 belong to Dennis Nilsen, Aileen Wuornos, Peter Manuel, Stephen Griffiths, Robert Pickton and Gary Ridgway. Using actors and lip-sync technology, the audio will be bought to life and will allow the audience will be taken inside the confessions of serial killers, face to face with evil. These police interrogations will be complimented by drama recon of the crimes themselves and further supported by expert and Police interviews. Professor...

Enjoy stacks of your favourite shows this Christmas
Posted on Tuesday 5th December 2017

Every night from 23rd until 31st December at 9pm, CBS Reality is giving you the chance to binge on your favourite shows with nights stacked with the best in true life drama.

Saturday 23rd: Troubled Teens – Jail Shock
Sunday 24th: Voice Of A Serial Killer
Monday 25th: Urban Legends
Tuesday 26th: Murder For Hire
Wednesday 27th: Hoarders: Family Secrets
Thursday 28th: Stalkers Who Kill
Friday 29th: 48 Hours
Saturday 30th: Killer Doctors On Death Row
Sunday 31st: Unsolved Mysteries

Spend Christmas in court!
Posted on Tuesday 5th December 2017

Love Judge Judy? You'll love CBS Reality over Christmas as we're delivering back-to-back episodes from 23rd until 31st December.

With her outspoken style, hard-hitting decisiveness and biting wit, Judge Judith Sheindlin single-handedly reinvented the courtroom genre and in the process has become a genuine pop culture phenomenon.

A former New York family court judge known for her ability to cut through a dispute and get to the core of the emotional issue at hand, Judge Judy acts as a true moral compass for people seeking guidance, resolution and a little common sense in their often complicated lives. Judge Judy’s goal is to make a permanent and worthwhile impression that will discourage repeat offender...

Interview with Professor David Wilson presenter of Voice of a Serial Killer
Posted on Tuesday 21st November 2017

Voice of a Serial Killer is the thrilling CBS Reality Original series that takes a fresh approach of bringing to life the nerve jangling real audio taken from the killer’s confessions. One of its presenters, Professor David Wilson took time to chat to us about this series.

CBSR: You were the youngest governing governor at the age of 29, what pressure did that add to what must be an incredibly stressful role?

DW: The pressure was one of youth and inexperience. Quite apart from the personal pressures that come with wanting to do a good job, there were inter personal pressures too. Some older staff were all too eager for me to fall fl...

Judge Judy
Friday 23 March
5.30 PM
Medical Detectives
Sunday 25 March
7.30 PM
Sins and Secrets
Sunday 25 March
8.00 PM